How to Challenge Unfair Insurance Disputes & Rejections

Insurance Disputes

How can I challenge my insurance claim rejection if I feel it was unfair?

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

Just because your insurer has rejected your claim, does not necessarily mean that your case is closed. If you think that you have been unfairly treated, here are some ways to get the insurer decision overturned.

What to do

Inform the insurance company as soon as you can following the event. It is sometimes a good idea to write the details of the event as soon as you can, and then use that as a reference to make the written claim.
Be consistent. Remember, it will be awkward if you want to change your story later on.
Keep all documents that are relevant to the claim.
Make sure the staff of the insurance company can get in touch with you.

If the claim is rejected?

Insuring your most valuable asset

While many people would consider their home or their car to be their most valuable asset, it's your ability to earn an income that is most important in shaping your financial future. Statistically, two thirds of working Australians will suffer an injury or illness that will sideline them for 90 days or more. The majority of these people would not be able to pay their mortgage or meet car finance and other loan commitments without adequate income insurance.

... compare rates & options ...

There are circumstances where you may in fact have the legal right to be reimbursed for your loss even though the insurer refused to pay the claim. Although you can sometimes make this judgement yourself, it is sometimes a good idea to get legal advice. See our fact sheets on "Disputes".

Check the policy

If the claim is rejected ask your insurer to identify specifically the clause of the contract on which they rely. If you do not have a current policy make sure they supply one.

What caused the loss?

If the insurer claims that you caused the loss, and this is in breach of the policy, make sure that this is so.

For instance, if you were smoking in bed at the time of a fire, and a fire caused this way is a breach of your policy, you may not in fact be in breach if the fire was caused by an electrical fault. In this case the fact that you were smoking in bed would be coincidental and not the cause of the fire.

Pre-existing conditions

The policy may stipulate that a known pre-existing situation or condition is not covered. For instance, if you have disability insurance but at the time you signed the policy you had a tumor. However, under the law it would be crucial whether you actually knew you had this condition. If you were unaware of it you should still be covered.

Ignorance of the terms

Under the law the insurer has a legal obligation to inform you about the restrictions in the insurance policy. This must be done before you sign the application and the policy is issued. This means (in part) that:

you must be given a copy of the policy; and
the wording of the policy must be clear and unambiguous.

If these pre-conditions were not met it may be possible to retain your coverage for your loss. Again, it may be necessary to obtain legal advice.

Is it worth the claim?

Many types of insurance contracts will have an excess. This is common in a car insurance contract, or similarly you may lose part of the no-claims bonus. Some companies now reward rating one drivers with a lifetime rating one guarantee. At times you will have to decide whether the amount of the claim is worth the long term loss that results from the effect on rating or no-claims bonuses, especially after taking into account the amount of the excess.

Published: Sunday, 1st Aug 2021
Author: Paige Estritori

Business Insurance Articles

Avoiding Underinsurance: How to Adequately Cover Your Growing Business

When it comes to protecting the vitality and financial health of a growing business, insurance is a keystone. Yet, amidst the day-to-day hustle of driving your business forward, it's surprisingly easy to overlook the adequacy of your insurance policies - a misstep that can lead to the perilous state of underinsurance. In this article, we will delve into the essential knowledge and strategies to ensure your business is sufficiently covered, shielding it from unexpected setbacks and losses. - read more

Business Interruption Insurance: Why It’s Crucial for Small Business Owners

Business interruption insurance is a type of coverage designed to compensate businesses for lost income and operational costs when they are unable to operate due to a covered event such as a natural disaster, fire, or other incidents that disrupt business operations. - read more

The Importance of Cyber Security: Protecting Your Small Business

Cyber security refers to the practices and technologies designed to protect computers, networks, programs, and data from unauthorized access, attacks, or damage. It's a crucial aspect of modern business operations, and understanding its importance is vital for all businesses, especially small ones. - read more

Common Insurance Mistakes Small Business Owners Should Avoid

Running a small business in Australia comes with its unique set of challenges and risks. One crucial aspect that every small business owner must consider is liability insurance. Liability insurance is designed to protect businesses from various claims and lawsuits that can arise in the course of their operations. Whether it's a customer slipping and falling in a store or a disgruntled employee filing a lawsuit, having the right insurance can provide a financial safety net. - read more

Key Factors to Consider When Comparing Business Insurance Options

Business insurance is a vital aspect of safeguarding your company's interests and mitigating potential risks. Whether you are a small startup or a well-established organization, having appropriate insurance coverage is essential for protecting your assets, finances, and reputation. - read more

Insurance News

Javln Strengthens Australian Market Position with Organiseit Acquisition

01 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori

In a strategic move to bolster its presence in the Australian insurance sector, New Zealand-based insurtech company Javln has acquired Organiseit, a prominent Australian document management system provider. This acquisition follows Javln's successful $6 million capital raise in October, earmarked for accelerating its growth strategy and expanding its footprint in Australia. - read more

Insurance Council Declares Catastrophe as Victoria Bushfires Intensify

01 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori

The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) has declared an insurance catastrophe in response to the escalating bushfires across Victoria, underscoring the profound impact of climate change on the nation's insurance landscape. Since January 7, bushfires have ravaged over 400,000 hectares of land, leading to a surge in insurance claims and raising alarms about the increasing frequency and severity of such events. - read more

ASIC Takes Legal Action Against Budget Direct for Alleged Misleading Discounts

01 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has commenced legal proceedings against Auto & General, the parent company of Budget Direct, alleging that the insurer engaged in misleading conduct regarding promised discounts to customers. The case centers on claims that tens of thousands of Budget Direct policyholders were overcharged premiums over several years due to the withdrawal of discounts that had been previously offered. - read more

IAG's Strategic Expansion: 90% Acquisition of RACQ Insurance

24 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori

Insurance Australia Group (IAG) has announced the acquisition of a 90% stake in RACQ Insurance for $855 million. This strategic move is expected to bolster IAG's gross written premiums by approximately $1.3 billion, reinforcing its position in the Australian insurance market. - read more

Suncorp's Impressive 89% Profit Increase in H1 2025

24 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori

Suncorp Group has reported a remarkable 89% increase in net profit for the first half of 2025, with earnings per share reaching A$86.56. This substantial growth reflects the company's strong performance in the Australian insurance sector. - read more

Click for more Insurance News

Knowledgebase

Exclusion:
Specific conditions or circumstances for which the insurance policy does not provide coverage.